• Dedicated to fact-based journalism and commentary on the state of education in New Jersey
On Scaling Up Successful Educational ModelsOn Scaling Up Successful Educational ModelsOn Scaling Up Successful Educational ModelsOn Scaling Up Successful Educational Models
  • Latest News
  • NJER-TV
  • Communities
      • Asbury Park
      • Camden
      • Jersey City
      • Lakewood
      • Montclair
      • Newark
      • Paterson
      • Trenton
  • Policy
    • By The Numbers
    • COVID-19
    • DOE
    • Education on the Ballot
    • Educational Equity
    • Press Release
    • State
  • Voices
    • Parent Voices
    • Teacher Voices
  • Opinion
    • NJER Commentary
  • About
    • Laura Waters
  • Subscribe
✕
Sunday Leftovers
January 9, 2011
Weighing Small Scale V. Large
January 10, 2011
Show all

On Scaling Up Successful Educational Models

By Laura Waters at January 10, 2011
Topic
  • News
Tags
  • school choice

Here’s Eduwonk’s Andrew Rotherham who ponders

how consistently wrong education’s wise men and women generally are about scale. I can remember meetings just a few years ago where the “experts” solemnly informed us that KIPP (the high-performing network of public charter middle schools) was nice but would never get past a dozen or maybe two dozen schools. Now there are 100. Will there be 10,000? Probably not. More than 100? Certainly. Or consider Teach For America, still widely derided as marginal. And sure, it will never replace other methods of teacher preparation but it is the largest teacher preparation program in the country (5K a year coming up) – and gets the best results overall. The list goes on. The point is that a lot of ideas that haven’t been tried are now being tried and we have a lot to learn about scale and scaling. In addition, there are a lot of policies and barriers. On charter schools, for instance, it’s sort of ridiculous to talk about scaling them when they get 20 percent less funding than other public schools.

Share
Laura Waters
Laura Waters

Related posts

May 25, 2023

Three Takeaways From New Report on COVID and Public Education’s Current Condition


Read more
May 25, 2023

LILLEY: Montclair Mayor/NJEA President Owns District’s Enrollment Loss and Teacher Lay-Offs


Read more
May 24, 2023

Two Senators Propose Law That Would Ban Book-Banning in Schools


Read more

3 Comments

  1. Nicholas says:
    January 10, 2011 at 4:41 pm

    Aren't state and local governments reluctant to pump funding into some charters as there can be some real questions about whether the charter organization (in some cases kind of distant entities) is going to stick with it beyond a year or two?

    There's also the issue that less of the total operations budget can be reliably put towards education, right? In New Orleans, the charters are mostly responsible for contracting their own busing, meal service, etc. unless they are part of a larger federation of charters, which means higher per-pupil costs for these logistics than larger school systems face.

    Your blog is really great! I always look forward to new posts in my Reader.

    Reply
  2. NJ Left Behind says:
    January 10, 2011 at 5:45 pm

    Thanks for the comments, Nicholas. Actually in NJ (and most states) there's a rigorous screening process for any group that wants to open a charter, which includes long-term financials. You're right that budgeting is more difficult in NJ, where there's no facilities assistance. Traditional public districts have no need to rent or buy facilities without state assistance, but here charters are on their own.

    Reply
  3. Nicholas says:
    January 12, 2011 at 12:42 am

    I guess the question of permanence of charter-backing here is complicated by the nature of the arrival of the charters – it seems consistently up-for-grabs how long schools/districts will remain in state (rather than local board), and thus charter, control. They are supposed to revert back to local control soon, but no one seems to know for sure and so I suppose part of the problem lies in finding financial support from investors/donors when no one can be sure that the school will still be theirs to fund a couple years down the road.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to the
NJER Morning Report

The NJ Education Report is your trusted source for news and commentary about schools across our state. Get the latest in your inbox.

Subscribe

Teachers and Parents Join Together To Advocate for Educational Change

https://youtu.be/LUA0yjPXzII

Newark Community Assails Superintendent and School Board For Failing to Address Racism

https://youtu.be/Oy6gu46SDaQ

LANGUAGE

POPULAR

Asbury Park Lakewood Montclair Newark

MORE TOPICS

CONNECT WITH NJER

SUGGEST AN ARTICLE IDEA, SEND A NEWS TIP OR SUBMIT A PRESS RELEASE

Submit details

NJ Education Report

NJER is dedicated to fact-based journalism and commentary on the state of education in New Jersey, with a commitment to voicing the concerns of parents, students, teachers and school leaders.

Subscribe

About

Laura Waters

Standards & Ethics

Privacy Policy

Advertising Opportunities

NJ Education Report
© 2023 NJ Education Report. All Rights Reserved.