• Dedicated to fact-based journalism and commentary on the state of education in New Jersey
JAMES: Murphy Just Put a Ceiling On My Daughter’s FutureJAMES: Murphy Just Put a Ceiling On My Daughter’s FutureJAMES: Murphy Just Put a Ceiling On My Daughter’s FutureJAMES: Murphy Just Put a Ceiling On My Daughter’s Future
  • Latest News
  • NJER-TV
  • Communities
      • Asbury Park
      • Camden
      • Jersey City
      • Lakewood
      • Montclair
      • Newark
      • Paterson
      • Trenton
  • Policy
    • By The Numbers
    • COVID-19
    • DOE
    • Education on the Ballot
    • Educational Equity
    • Press Release
    • State
  • Voices
    • Parent Voices
    • Teacher Voices
  • Opinion
    • NJER Commentary
  • About
    • Laura Waters
  • Subscribe
✕
New Jersey School Leaders ‘Confused’ By New Masks-in-Schools Guidance
February 28, 2022
COMMENTARY: Trenton Mothers Plead With Murphy, ‘Don’t Cut Our Children’s Wings’
March 1, 2022
Show all

JAMES: Murphy Just Put a Ceiling On My Daughter’s Future

By Oscar James at February 28, 2022
Topic
  • DOE News
  • Education on the Ballot
  • Newark
  • Opinion
Tags
  • Angelica Allen-McMillian
  • Black Parents
  • Black Students
  • Gov. Phil Murphy
  • Murphy Administration
  • New Jersey Department of Education
  • New Jersey Public Charter School Assocation
  • Newark
  • Newark Public Schools
  • Parent Voices
  • Private Schools
  • Public Charter Schools
  • Student Achievement

You all know I wear a lot of hats. Housing developer. Community activist. Political observer.

But by far my most important role is that of father to my children. And right now, my daughter’s education is being threatened. Let me explain the situation:

The other day, my daughter (who is in second grade at Philips Academy Charter School in Newark), looked up at me and asked: “Dad – will I be able to stay at my school forever?”

“You can’t stay anywhere forever, honey,” I told her, trying to deflect.

She didn’t let it go. “No, will I be able to stay there through high school?”

The question broke my heart. Because until a few weeks ago, I thought the answer would be yes, of course. But in January, Governor Murphy and Acting Education Commissioner McMillan denied the requests for seven high-performing charter schools – including Philips – to serve more students. Now, hundreds of kids in Trenton, Newark, Paterson, New Brunswick, and Kearny are going to be immediately shut out of the schools their families love. Thousands more will be denied the opportunities they deserve. Because of the Governor’s decision, Phillips won’t be allowed to grow into a high school as planned. Because of this decision, my daughter has a glass ceiling on her future.

So I hope it comes as no surprise that I am fired up, angry, and ready to speak out. And I talk to lots of parents who feel the same way. These are parents who voted for the Governor in his tough re-election campaign last year, and now they feel betrayed.

We – and so many other families – were counting on that high school. To be honest, Philips is the reason I stayed in Newark. I know what’s at stake: for most kids in Newark, the choice is between a failing district high school or a private school outside of the city. I wasn’t prepared to make that choice when it came to my own daughter.

I remember thinking: “for once, my daughter can stay in Newark, go to a public school, and get the same quality of education she’d get at a private high school.” It seemed both too good to be true and exactly what she deserved – what any kid deserves.

What makes me so fired up about this is not only the Governor’s decision, but his hypocrisy. He sent his own children to private schools – the highest level of school choice that a parent can exercise. Then he turns around and denies Black and brown parents the same choice. It’s just wrong.

Phillips is a Tier 1 school, which means it is one of the best schools in the entire state. Families couldn’t be happier. It has a clear plan to grow into a high school. So what exactly was missing? Why weren’t they approved? Governor Murphy says he doesn’t care about labels, but if this school wasn’t a charter school, would he have embraced us with open arms?

These are questions that we deserve answers to. Or better yet, the Governor could make it clear where he stands, put the children first, and reverse his decisions. I won’t hold my breath for that to happen, but I sincerely hope he comes to his senses.

Governor – Newark stood with you when you needed us. Now, we need you to have our back and let our children learn.

Share
Oscar James
Oscar James

Related posts

May 25, 2023

Newark Parents’ Support For City Charter Schools Continues Upward Trend


Read more
May 24, 2023

Newark School District Is Using Taxpayer Money To Claw Back a Crumbling Building—But It Won’t Say How Much


Read more
May 23, 2023

ChatGPT Is Here To Stay: Here’s How It Can Help Students Recover From COVID Learning Loss


Read more

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to the
NJER Morning Report

The NJ Education Report is your trusted source for news and commentary about schools across our state. Get the latest in your inbox.

Subscribe

Teachers and Parents Join Together To Advocate for Educational Change

https://youtu.be/LUA0yjPXzII

Newark Community Assails Superintendent and School Board For Failing to Address Racism

https://youtu.be/Oy6gu46SDaQ

LANGUAGE

POPULAR

Asbury Park Lakewood Montclair Newark

MORE TOPICS

CONNECT WITH NJER

SUGGEST AN ARTICLE IDEA, SEND A NEWS TIP OR SUBMIT A PRESS RELEASE

Submit details

NJ Education Report

NJER is dedicated to fact-based journalism and commentary on the state of education in New Jersey, with a commitment to voicing the concerns of parents, students, teachers and school leaders.

Subscribe

About

Laura Waters

Standards & Ethics

Privacy Policy

Advertising Opportunities

NJ Education Report
© 2023 NJ Education Report. All Rights Reserved.