
New Partnership Wants to Send Extra Money To NJ Public Schools. Can Gov. Sherrill Get to ‘Yes’?
November 16, 2026Part 2: Is the Ed Department Trashing Years of Student Learning Data or Not?
Last week I asked whether the New Jersey Department of Education, after assuring the public that new standardized tests would be comparable to previous ones, was reneging on that promise. I had asked the DOE for clarification but at the time of publication, the DOE had not yet responded to my request.
Yesterday it did. As promised, here is an update.
According to a department spokesperson,
“The Department remains committed to understanding student performance over time. The 2026 assessment results reflect significant changes, including alignment to new academic standards, a new reporting scale, revised performance levels, and new cut scores defining proficiency, that were approved in September. Given these factors, the Department does not recommend directly comparing publicly reported proficiency rates between 2026 and prior years. Accordingly, the Department has advised that the publicly reported 2026 results establish a new baseline. A linking study is under development to provide additional context for statewide analysis of the 2026 results.
For educators and families, the most important takeaway is that the 2026 results show how students performed against the new 2023 New Jersey Student Learning Standards and serve as the foundation for reporting results moving forward.”
Let’s unpack.
The primary message from the DOE is the 2026 statewide test results — 51% proficiency in reading, 41.7% in math, and 25% in science— are not comparable and constitute “a new baseline.” If that’s true, than any insights we’ve gleaned since the old NJSLAs debuted in 2019, like proficiency trends or the effectiveness of various interventions, may be less compelling than previously thought. Some school leaders are taking that message and running with it: In Newark, district officials said “changes to the tests’ content and scoring mean the results cannot be directly compared with those of previous years.” Thus, results showing only 29% of students can read at grade level, a drop from last year’s 34%, is nothing to get flustered about.
I think the DOE is being too hard on itself.
Think about it: the DOE’s presentation on November 4th* about test scores includes a bar graph from 2016-2026 which seems to show some stability year-to-year, with ELA (reading) down two points and math scores flat. So maybe we have maintained the ability to look at year-to-year trends, although our kids are not making as much progress as we’d like.
Additionally, the DOE says in its response that “a linking study is under development to provide additional context for statewide analysis of the 2026 results.” A linking study examines, in this case, two different assessments and interprets how we can compare them as we move from one to the other (see more here) so you’d think there would be some anticipation for valid comparisons. As the DOE made it clear last spring, it was committed to being able to “compare tests from year to year and made intentional design decisions to ensure we can compare this year’s test to last year’s.” That’s why it was doing the linking study, “which will confirm that student performance this year can be compared to prior years to continue to monitor growth and not lose the trend line.”
So can we compare? Maybe yes: the trend line above and the linking study (whenever/if ever we see it) will prove we have continuity. Maybe no, because it’s a “new baseline.”
This does not seem like the kind of message the DOE should be sending to the public, although the responsibility for this obfuscation is on the Murphy Administration. Maybe the new DOE is just cleaning up the mess.
Or maybe we’re too focused on hair-splitting technicalities. Instead, we might consider what our goals are for NJ students. Reading scores peaked in 2018-2019 and we still haven’t recovered half a decade after the pandemic. Six out of 10 NJ students don’t meet expectations in math. It’s worth noting that NJ’s accountability plan submitted to the feds in 2024 says by 2030 we will “close the gap between baseline performance and the future goal (100% proficient) by 20% over six years.” Instead, we’re either not making any progress or losing ground.
NJ Ed Report is grateful for the DOE’s responsiveness (and has asked for an update of that linking study).
*You can also access the presentation by going here and clicking on #4 on the agenda.



